Because it is an
introduction to the subject of postmodernism, Glenn
Ward's book remains at the level of synopsis and
summary. However, it does a decent job of scanning
the whole terrain. It lays out a useful map for
further study.
Coming at it
after my extended journey into
the subject, I appreciated Ward's
ability to tell me succinctly where I had been and
what I had learned. (In fact, I doubt that his book
would be as meaningful to someone just starting out
to "teach yourself" about postmodernism.)
One of my undone
postmodern projects is to devise a semester course
of study introducing postmodernism. I bogged down in the plethora
of materials and plurality of possible approaches
(while answering new sirens). With Ward in hand, I
think I could complete the syllabus and units in
short order. It would be unnecessary to add much to
his main topics and his presentations of main writers
on postmodernism.
POSTMODERNISM
IS EVERYWHERE
Ward rightly, in my view,
starts with the understanding that
"postmodernism is everywhere." (1) It is
not confined to literary or cultural studies but
resonates throughout academic and popular culture.
Although the fever surrounding postmodernism has
subsided, Ward helpfully advises us to think of it as
a persistent set of ideas that help explain where the
world has come. (4)
Ward is also right, I
think, to begin with the question of historical
periodization. (5-13) My readings in postmodernism
from the start have fascinated me because of their
power to throw the preceding modernist
experience into sharp relief. As someone
who grew up in the high modern period, the 1940s and
1950s, I have been spending my mature years trying to
become conscious of the modernist "givens"
of which I was not conscious as they operated through
much of my life.
THE
ARTS OF IMPURITY
In two chapters on "arts
of impurity," Ward draws the distinctions
between modernist and postmodernist esthetic values.
He starts appropriately with
architecture,
where postmodernism as a perspective first took hold,
and moves on to literature and art. (14-50)
In a chapter titled
"The Trouble With Reality" (51-79), Ward
focuses on the theories of French theorist
Jean Baudrillard. Here he links Baudrillard's
idea of the simulacrum (or hyper-reality) to earlier
social analysis in Marxist thought (72-74). That link with Marx
is a valuable window that opens on such thinkers as
Walter Benjamin (75) and Marshall McLuhan (77).
In "Taking
Meaning Apart" (80-104), Ward introduces the
changes in language study that underlie postmodern
theory. He pays respects to the founding work of
Ferdinand de Saussure, identifies the foundational
leaning of structuralism and the subsequent
anti-foundational tendency of poststructuralism.
Julia Kristeva's opposition to essentialism in gender
along with her championing of a "feminine"
tongue comes in for Ward's attention (93). That leads
to a look at Jacques Derrida's deconstructionist
treatment of philosophical, linguistic, and literary
texts. (94-104)
WHO
IS THE POSTMODERN SELF?
"Identity Crisis Part 1"
(105-126) turns attention to a postmodern view of the
self or subject and the way that view differs from
the modernist view. Ward emphasizes the fundamentally
social and constructivist characteristics of the self
in postmodernist thought and life. Because the self
is a social construct, not an essential core of
timeless value, it can change according to styles.
Ward situates the issues of identity largely in urban
life. (110-111). He explains how the changeability of
the self leads to interest in "cyberpeople"
who combine human and electronic capabilities
(112-114) and to novel permutations on sexuality
(115-116). He highlights for illustrative purposes
the sexual/gender variations in the public persona of
Madonna (117-120) and the photographic self-portraits
of Cindy Sherman (120-123).
"Identity Crisis
Part 2" (127-154) continues Ward's survey of
identity and selfhood by examining Michel
Foucault's ideas on the "invention"
of the subject through discourses (127-133). Then he
takes a shot at explaining how Jacques Lacan sought
to explain how the Freudian notion of the total
personality was a mistake, how selfhood never escapes
from an unstable, unfulfilled condition. (133-136) A
quick and inadequate nod to "the politics of
desire" of Gilles Deleuze and Felix
Guattari follows
(136-137). And that leads to a nod to the role of the
Frankfurt School, including Marcuse, Adorno,
and Horkheimer, who brought a Marxist-based critical
theory to bear on the conditions of modernity
(137-140).
Having established
the unstable identity of the self in postmodern
conditions, Ward then winds up his foray into the
"identity crisis" of postmodernism by
discussing the problems of authorial
"expression" in literature and "the
death of the author." He explains a bit about
the substitute notions for approaching literature as
an "intertextual" exercise, in which the
language not the author speaks. (143-154)
THE
THEORIES OF POSTMODERNISM
In his final chapter,
"Theorising the Broken World," (155-184),
we learn about Jean-Francois Lyotard's
critique of
"objective" science and his notion of
"metanarratives" as dominant cultural
determiners. (156-160) Then Ward tries--rather
unsuccessfully--to explain how postmodern cultural
theory has modified Marxist class theory to deal with
the new social conditions (160-162). He shows how
"micropolitics" and "techniques of
daily life" have replaced the pursuit of grand
narratives of social transformation, including
classical Marxism (162-165). Ward next glances at the
thinking of Jurgen Habermas (166-168) on the rescue of the
Enlightenment; and of the American geographer Edward
Soja (169-171), who seeks to redefine spatial
occupancy as a key concept in the analysis of
postmodern society. Fredric Jameson's major contributions to the
cultural definitions of postmodern culture, drawn
from a neo-Marxist reservoir of social theory, come
in for due attention (171-174). Ward then explains
how "theorising the city" emerges from the
thinking of Jameson and others (174-176).
Finally, Ward
connects the rise of "globalization"
to
postmodernism (176-184). He touches on the issues of
"shifting boundaries" in a technologically
connected world (177); "globalised
identities" (178); "post-coloniality"
(179; the inclusive language that emerges from global
theories (180); the complexities of negotiating from
the "center" to the "margin"
(181-184).
Ward ends with
"an inconclusion" (184). He thus
accentuates the elusive, open-ended nature of any
attempt to get one's mind totally around the issues
associated with postmodernism. Yet he believes that
the term postmodernism, "however slippery and
contradictory it might be, offers a way into debates
about contemporary societies, cultures and
lifestyles." (184)